Welcome to yEd Q&A!
Here you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of the community and yEd developers. And you can tell us your most wanted feature requests.


Application crash loading malformed GML

0 votes

When attempting to load a GML graph containing a node whose ID and group ID are identical, yEd hangs (and proceeds to allocate as much memory as the JVM will allow).

This graph demonstrates the problem:

graph [
node [ id 0    label "blow up"    gid 0 ]

I'll fix my code that's generating the graph...but can we get a load error instead of an application crash? : )

yEd 3.13 on Java 1.6.0_30 with DCE VM (I'll uninstall to reproduce this error if needed).

in Help by (260 points)

1 Answer

+1 vote
Best answer
Thank you for your report. However, GML is officially discontinued and is no longer maintained in any way. (It is included in yEd as a favor for legacy users.) Moreover, this is (strictly speaking) not a bug in yEd or its GML processor. As such chances are very slim that we will improve yEd's behavior in this regard. Nevertheless I have added corresponding request for enhancement in our internal issue tracking system.
by [yWorks] (151k points)
selected by
I hadn't realized GML is deprecated, thanks for pointing that out.
I chose GML as my output format because it's the simplest to produce, but it sounds like it's about time to move up to GraphML. Luckily changing over won't be a big hassle!
It "feels like" a bug because even bad input should not be able to crash the app.   : )
Legal Disclosure | Privacy Policy